False Confessions
Part 11 of Series: John Moss
Multiple Confessions
In Triple Murder
Probe Provoke Questions:
Did Juvenile Do It?
By Elizabeth Perry
The Innocence Institute of Point Park University
An outlaw motorcycle club associate, Paul Reggettz, 35, worked for UPS, while his wife, Vanessa, 26, cared for their two children. He later admitted he repeatedly beat his wife and abused his family, once telling his son “he wished he’d never been born.”
Twelve days before Christmas in 1979, Mr. Reggettz told police he found the murdered bodies of Mrs. Reggettz, Paul Eric, 7, and Bernadette, 4, in their St. Albans, West Virginia home.
Mrs. Reggettz, 5-foot-tall and 94 pounds, was beaten strangled with an extension chord and stabbed with household scissors. Her son was choked with a power chord from a radio and drowned. Her daughter was strangled with a vacuum cleaner cord and hanged on a door facing their Christmas tree.
A Deeply Flawed Investigation
State Police immediately suspected Mr. Reggettz because he was deep in debt, had numerous domestic problems and showed no emotion after summoning them.
After 14 ½ in custody, when he said he was tossed on the ground and had a gun held to his head, Mr. Reggettz confessed.
He said an argument that began with his wife over the children’s rambunctious play escalated after she pulled his hunting rifle on him. He grabbed the gun, beat her with and stabbed her with scissors to be certain she was dead.
Mr. Reggettz told police he bound and strangled his son then put him in a water filled tub because Paul Eric “liked to swim.” Bernadette had been hung by her neck because she “liked to swing.”
The next morning, he reenacted the killings for the officers at his home and was charged with all three murders.
Later, Mr. Reggettz testified police led him through the confessions after he decided to “Tell them whatever they wanted to hear so they would leave me alone.”
Bloody Questions
While police had a confession and a motive, one piece didn’t fit – blood collected at the scene by a Fred Zain, a West Virginia Crime Lab specialist who would later face numerous challenges about his work, did not match any family member.
Concurrently, Mr. Moss’s uncle told police his delinquent nephew was in the area prior to his incarceration for the rape and shooting of a female bus driver and might know something.
In the prison, troopers secured three vials of his blood and Mr. Zain ruled blood splatters from the crime scene matched Mr. Moss.
Not yet ready to file murder charges, troopers saw an opportunity to talk with Mr. Moss, who was incarcerated in Ohio on a violent assault case, when they saw he had a court date in an unrelated case that later was dropped.
On the six hour drive he was interrogated without a lawyer or parent present and claims he was beaten while in handcuffs until he confessed to the Reggettz murders.
Stop the Tape
The 27-minute taped confession took an hour to record because troopers testified they stopped the tape “two or three times” to clarify things that originally conflicted with the physical evidence.
When asked what else he did to Mrs. Reggettz, who was stabbed with scissors, Mr. Moss replied, “I stabbed her with a knife or something.” When asked again if he remembered what he stabbed her with, Mr. Moss said, “No, I don’t know, I stabbed her.” Recently, he said he did not know what happened to Mrs. Reggettz, but police coached him before and during his confession.
Two days later other troopers testified he confessed again, though neither recorded this second confession on tape or in writing, and Mr. Moss denied it.
Thirteen days later, Judge John Hey, who later surrendered his law license for drinking on the bench, released Mr. Reggettz after he passed the second lie detector test. He failed the first one.
Trial By Error
After four years, West Virginia prosecutors succeeded in certifying Mr. Moss as an adult and his trial began in February 1984, with his lawyers trying to shift blame to Mr. Reggettz due to his own confessions.
On the stand, Mr. Reggettz admitted he fought with his wife and frequently beat her, but insisted he did not kill his family. He said he confessed not out of guilt but fear.
After a jury listened to Mr. Moss’ taped confession, he denied the crimes and said he confessed because of police abuse.
The blood evidence sealed Mr. Moss’ fate when Mr. Zain, a serologist, tied blood found at the scene to the teenager who says he wasn’t there.
On April 30, 1984, Mr. Moss was convicted of the murders and sentenced to three life sentences. He won a second trial in 1990 because of prejudicial out of court comments by a prosecutor, only to be convicted again.
In his closing arguments of the second trial, the prosecutor told a jury even if they discounted the confessions: “Look at the blood; look at the reliability of the blood, ladies and gentlemen.”
Discredited Serologist
Three years later, a wide-ranging investigation revealed Mr. Zain, the serologist, repeatedly faked forensic evidence he did not test properly.
Gary Wells, a psychology professor at Iowa State University and expert in identification issues who’s written about the Zain scandal, said the supposed expert failed organic chemistry.
“Fred Zain couldn’t do these tests, he didn’t know how, he just made them up.” said Mr. Wells.
The West Virginia Supreme Court issued a decree in 1993 condemning any testimony or evidence offered by Mr. Zain as “invalid, unreliable and inadmissible” and barred its use in deciding whether or not to award a new trial after a panel investigating 30 cases in which he was involved and found he falsified evidence in all.
Appeals Denied
Mr. Moss’ appealed, but was denied because of his confession and Mr. Zain’s work in his case had been aided and supervised by another serologist. Mr. Zain died in 2002.
Mr. Moss, now 52, maintains he is innocent and refuses to give up.
When asked about his confidence in Mr. Moss’ conviction, Judge James Stuckey, the prosecuting attorney in the first trial remained: “Very confident, I don’t hesitate; I don’t have a doubt in my mind that the juries made the right decision. Zain has certainly given me pause with scientific evidence and death penalty, but not with John Moss.”
Multiple Confessions
In Triple Murder
Probe Provoke Questions:
Did Juvenile Do It?
By Elizabeth Perry
The Innocence Institute of Point Park University
An outlaw motorcycle club associate, Paul Reggettz, 35, worked for UPS, while his wife, Vanessa, 26, cared for their two children. He later admitted he repeatedly beat his wife and abused his family, once telling his son “he wished he’d never been born.”
Twelve days before Christmas in 1979, Mr. Reggettz told police he found the murdered bodies of Mrs. Reggettz, Paul Eric, 7, and Bernadette, 4, in their St. Albans, West Virginia home.
Mrs. Reggettz, 5-foot-tall and 94 pounds, was beaten strangled with an extension chord and stabbed with household scissors. Her son was choked with a power chord from a radio and drowned. Her daughter was strangled with a vacuum cleaner cord and hanged on a door facing their Christmas tree.
A Deeply Flawed Investigation
State Police immediately suspected Mr. Reggettz because he was deep in debt, had numerous domestic problems and showed no emotion after summoning them.
After 14 ½ in custody, when he said he was tossed on the ground and had a gun held to his head, Mr. Reggettz confessed.
He said an argument that began with his wife over the children’s rambunctious play escalated after she pulled his hunting rifle on him. He grabbed the gun, beat her with and stabbed her with scissors to be certain she was dead.
Mr. Reggettz told police he bound and strangled his son then put him in a water filled tub because Paul Eric “liked to swim.” Bernadette had been hung by her neck because she “liked to swing.”
The next morning, he reenacted the killings for the officers at his home and was charged with all three murders.
Later, Mr. Reggettz testified police led him through the confessions after he decided to “Tell them whatever they wanted to hear so they would leave me alone.”
Bloody Questions
While police had a confession and a motive, one piece didn’t fit – blood collected at the scene by a Fred Zain, a West Virginia Crime Lab specialist who would later face numerous challenges about his work, did not match any family member.
Concurrently, Mr. Moss’s uncle told police his delinquent nephew was in the area prior to his incarceration for the rape and shooting of a female bus driver and might know something.
In the prison, troopers secured three vials of his blood and Mr. Zain ruled blood splatters from the crime scene matched Mr. Moss.
Not yet ready to file murder charges, troopers saw an opportunity to talk with Mr. Moss, who was incarcerated in Ohio on a violent assault case, when they saw he had a court date in an unrelated case that later was dropped.
On the six hour drive he was interrogated without a lawyer or parent present and claims he was beaten while in handcuffs until he confessed to the Reggettz murders.
Stop the Tape
The 27-minute taped confession took an hour to record because troopers testified they stopped the tape “two or three times” to clarify things that originally conflicted with the physical evidence.
When asked what else he did to Mrs. Reggettz, who was stabbed with scissors, Mr. Moss replied, “I stabbed her with a knife or something.” When asked again if he remembered what he stabbed her with, Mr. Moss said, “No, I don’t know, I stabbed her.” Recently, he said he did not know what happened to Mrs. Reggettz, but police coached him before and during his confession.
Two days later other troopers testified he confessed again, though neither recorded this second confession on tape or in writing, and Mr. Moss denied it.
Thirteen days later, Judge John Hey, who later surrendered his law license for drinking on the bench, released Mr. Reggettz after he passed the second lie detector test. He failed the first one.
Trial By Error
After four years, West Virginia prosecutors succeeded in certifying Mr. Moss as an adult and his trial began in February 1984, with his lawyers trying to shift blame to Mr. Reggettz due to his own confessions.
On the stand, Mr. Reggettz admitted he fought with his wife and frequently beat her, but insisted he did not kill his family. He said he confessed not out of guilt but fear.
After a jury listened to Mr. Moss’ taped confession, he denied the crimes and said he confessed because of police abuse.
The blood evidence sealed Mr. Moss’ fate when Mr. Zain, a serologist, tied blood found at the scene to the teenager who says he wasn’t there.
On April 30, 1984, Mr. Moss was convicted of the murders and sentenced to three life sentences. He won a second trial in 1990 because of prejudicial out of court comments by a prosecutor, only to be convicted again.
In his closing arguments of the second trial, the prosecutor told a jury even if they discounted the confessions: “Look at the blood; look at the reliability of the blood, ladies and gentlemen.”
Discredited Serologist
Three years later, a wide-ranging investigation revealed Mr. Zain, the serologist, repeatedly faked forensic evidence he did not test properly.
Gary Wells, a psychology professor at Iowa State University and expert in identification issues who’s written about the Zain scandal, said the supposed expert failed organic chemistry.
“Fred Zain couldn’t do these tests, he didn’t know how, he just made them up.” said Mr. Wells.
The West Virginia Supreme Court issued a decree in 1993 condemning any testimony or evidence offered by Mr. Zain as “invalid, unreliable and inadmissible” and barred its use in deciding whether or not to award a new trial after a panel investigating 30 cases in which he was involved and found he falsified evidence in all.
Appeals Denied
Mr. Moss’ appealed, but was denied because of his confession and Mr. Zain’s work in his case had been aided and supervised by another serologist. Mr. Zain died in 2002.
Mr. Moss, now 52, maintains he is innocent and refuses to give up.
When asked about his confidence in Mr. Moss’ conviction, Judge James Stuckey, the prosecuting attorney in the first trial remained: “Very confident, I don’t hesitate; I don’t have a doubt in my mind that the juries made the right decision. Zain has certainly given me pause with scientific evidence and death penalty, but not with John Moss.”
22 Comments:
At 2:39 PM,
DAByron said…
I wish I could be as sure as the judicial system that John Moss is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Maybe he did decide to go there to steal something. Maybe he just picked a really bad night to do it. He might even have been capable of attacking Vanessa but what was done to those children........ That crime was too up close and personal. It's much easier to blame a kid who had repeated run-ins with the law than to even remotely think that a husband and father would be capable of such a horrible thing. Paul Reggettz III also confessed - he even walked the police through the scene describing what he had done and his confession more closely matched the medical examiner's findings. Unfortunately, Mr. Reggettz passed away last spring, an "innocent" man, so those of us left behind will never know the truth.
Deborah Reggettz Byron
At 4:51 PM,
k said…
There is very significant evidence missing from this article.
Mr. Moss had more than youthful indiscretions or "run ins" with the law. At the time he became a suspect in this case, he was in prison in Ohio for raping a woman and beating her so savagely that here eye-ball came of her head. He was under investigation for another brutal crime in the same area when he became a suspect in the Reggettz murder. Also, Fred Zain didn't do any of the testing in this case. He was under supervision at this time in his career. The actual testing was performed by a credible serologist. Zain only read the report into evidence. Also, the medical examiner fixed the time of death at around the time Moss claimed to be at the house - six hours before Reggettz finished his shift at UPS. Moss stole items from the house that were later recovered from the homes of friends and family members, right where he said they'd be. Also, most importantly, the early serology testing performed in this case exonerated a "confessed" killer - Reggettz - charged and imprisoned. Producing results that exonerated confessed killers was not part of Zain's MO. Reggettz had been in prison for months while the serology testing was going on and the State was building its case. But much to the chagrin of all involved, the serology testing was eliminating the man they had in custody.
Don't worry. The right man is in prison. Reggettz was an animal too. But Moss was a worse animal. It's just a very, very, very sad case because of the victims who had already suffered enough.
At 6:17 PM,
dstrattenfan said…
yep the right man is in prison..ask him how he got that nice 2 inch cut on the underside of his hand....Ill save u the time and answer it for u.....Vanessa gave it to him b4 he strangled beat and stabbed her while trying to protect her children...Yes Im related to Vanessa and the children Paul was a lot of things but a murderer isn't one of them
At 8:33 PM,
oakleyses said…
louboutin, louis vuitton outlet stores, louis vuitton outlet, coach factory outlet, tory burch outlet, michael kors outlet, true religion jeans, polo ralph lauren outlet, prada handbags, jordan shoes, burberry outlet, oakley sunglasses, longchamp outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, air max, prada outlet, longchamp handbags, true religion jeans, louboutin outlet, coach purses, coach outlet, gucci outlet, ray ban sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, oakley sunglasses cheap, christian louboutin shoes, louis vuitton handbags, oakley sunglasses, nike shoes, louis vuitton, longchamp handbags, michael kors outlet, air max, tiffany and co, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet, coach outlet store online, louboutin, kate spade outlet, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, tiffany and co, kate spade handbags, burberry outlet, nike free, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton outlet
At 8:52 PM,
oakleyses said…
sac louis vuitton, north face, air force, nike tn, hollister, vans pas cher, sac guess, north face, air max pas cher, vanessa bruno, ray ban sunglasses, air max, hollister, nike free pas cher, converse pas cher, barbour, abercrombie and fitch, hogan outlet, nike blazer, sac hermes, new balance pas cher, oakley pas cher, ray ban pas cher, polo ralph lauren, timberland, nike roshe run, ralph lauren, air jordan, sac louis vuitton, nike trainers, nike air max, michael kors pas cher, sac burberry, louis vuitton uk, air max, polo lacoste, nike roshe, louboutin, michael kors, lululemon, nike free, sac longchamp, michael kors, longchamp, true religion outlet, true religion outlet, louis vuitton, mulberry
At 8:52 PM,
oakleyses said…
chi flat iron, north face jackets, vans shoes, uggs outlet, marc jacobs, north face outlet, herve leger, reebok outlet, soccer jerseys, nike huarache, ugg pas cher, insanity workout, ghd, hollister, wedding dresses, soccer shoes, mcm handbags, canada goose outlet, ugg boots, mac cosmetics, abercrombie and fitch, ferragamo shoes, canada goose, babyliss pro, beats by dre, longchamp, celine handbags, p90x, ugg, rolex watches, instyler, ugg australia, birkin bag, canada goose jackets, ugg boots, giuseppe zanotti, uggs outlet, ugg boots, nike roshe run, valentino shoes, nfl jerseys, asics running shoes, bottega veneta, lululemon outlet, mont blanc, jimmy choo outlet, new balance shoes
At 9:09 PM,
oakleyses said…
louboutin, swarovski crystal, karen millen, hollister clothing store, ugg, iphone 6 cases, moncler, hollister, canada goose uk, ray ban, canada goose, juicy couture outlet, moncler, gucci, hollister, montre homme, converse shoes, canada goose, pandora charms, lancel, supra shoes, canada goose, converse, moncler, toms shoes, timberland boots, moncler, rolex watches, pandora jewelry, parajumpers, moncler, coach outlet store online, juicy couture outlet, links of london, oakley, louis vuitton, thomas sabo, moncler, vans, wedding dresses, ugg, swarovski, canada goose, air max, moncler outlet, baseball bats, air max, ralph lauren, pandora charms
At 12:40 AM,
750unique said…
2015-07-06song
soccer shoes for sale
pandora jewelry sale
toms shoes sale
ed hardy outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
rolex watches
football jerseys
longchamp sale
abercrombie kids
coach factory outlet
coach outlet store online
oakley sunglasses outlet
michael kors uk outlet
coach outlet
beats headphones
louboutin
replica watches rolex
polo outlet
true religion jeans outlet
cheap beats by dre
michael kors watches
oakley sunglasses
chanel handbags
snapbacks hats
kate spade outlet
pandora charms
ed hardy uk clothing
kate spade outlet
air max 2015
tory burch outlet online
gucci bags
toms shoes for women
pandora jewelry stores
oakley sunglasses outlet
hollister kids clothing
At 1:56 AM,
Lin Shijun said…
shijun 7.27
cheap nfl jerseys
michael kors outlet
jordan shoes
jordan retro 9
mont blanc mountain
gucci bags
louboutin
hollister outlet
oakley sunglasses
jordan pas cher femme
michael kors outlet online
ray-ban sunglasses
michael kors handbag
hollister kids
louis vuitton handbags
ed hardy clothing outlet
longchamp outlet
chanel handbags
coach outlet
coach outlet canada
tory burch outlet
jordan 6
michael kors outlet online
abercrombie kids
barbour uk
air max 95
pandora rings
chanel no 5
michael kors outlet
toms shoes
oakley sunglasses cheap
gucci handbags
hollister kids
michael kors uk
christian louboutin outlet
kobe bryant shoes for kids
fitflop sale
soccer jerseys
fitflop shoes
prada outlet
At 2:37 AM,
mohsin razzaq said…
when you can change the field that the album is Ian you change the ampere made of those abs so we have feelings in our hearts were changing the field that connects the stuff everything is made of and we literally are altering their physical reality in ways that sound miraculous in Western science again this is a great secret everyone knows except us because Western science is only arrived at this understanding you go these ancient indigenous traditions and cultures it's where they begin they begin with the understanding sure everything’s connected sure parted and then it takes one step further they say here I'll show you I'll show you how to create the fax in your body.
http://binaryoptionpay.com/
http://findbinaryoption.com/
http://findbestbinaryoption.com/
http://findtopbinaryoption.com/
http://binaryoptiontopbroker.com/
http://binaryoptionwork.com/
http://binaryoptionworkhelp.com/
http://binaryoptionworksupport.com/
http://listedbinaryoption.com/
http://reliablebinaryoption.com/
At 8:13 AM,
http://expressvitrier.fr/vitrier-saintdenis-93200.html said…
Nous sommes toujours à votre service
At 4:04 AM,
raybanoutlet001 said…
moncler jackets
coach outlet
tennessee titans jersey
hugo boss sale
ralph lauren uk
true religion outlet store
nike shoes
christian louboutin sale
nike shoes
ugg boots
2017.7.25
At 1:47 AM,
raybanoutlet001 said…
cheap jordan shoes
oakley sunglasses
michael kors canada
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors uk
instyler max
asics outlet
rolex replica
gucci shoes
coach factory outlet
At 1:47 AM,
Pansys Silvaz said…
qzz0601
tory burch outlet
ugg boots
canada goose jackets
ugg outlet
suns jerseys
converse shoes
kate spade outlet
nuggets jerseys
marc jacobs outlet
michael kors
At 3:58 AM,
te12 said…
qzz0728
louboutin shoes
pandora charms outlet
prada shoes
asics shoes
adidas yeezy
coach outlet store online
nike shoes
nhl jerseys
ray ban eyeglasses
jordan shoes
At 2:28 AM,
5689 said…
zzzzz2018.7.30
canada goose outlet
nike air max 95 ultra
canada goose outlet
uggs outlet
air max 90
pandora jewelry
jimmy choo outlet
nike factory outlet
moncler outlet
supreme shirt
At 4:30 AM,
4578 said…
0801jejeair jordan chaussure prix Loup new balance basketball apparel Gris / Noir / Volt, Blanc / Noir, Noir / new balance bordeaux france Blanc / Rouge Varsity et air jordan basket femme Noir / Gris Foncé / Noir sont nike air zoom pegasus 34 Chaussures tous facilement disponibles à l'achat dès new balance blanc beige maintenant. La fonctionnalité Crystal Clear de acheter nike roshe run pas cher Loctite GO2 Glue guidera les individus à nike homme asos effectuer des réparations invisibles avec moins de tracas.
At 4:00 AM,
jeje said…
adidas zx flux homme maroc Les sandales, asics gel pulse femme pas cher les bottes et les chaussures de loisirs d'aujourd'hui combinent la mode, la durabilité et chaussure nike air max thea femme pas cher l'ingénierie sonore pour créer des baskets qui expriment la personnalité et chaussure nike pas cher femme offrent une protection spécifique. Les membres artificiels, les humanoïdes, les différents basket nike air jordan 9 retro cadet capteurs qui sont reliés à votre corps, etc. Pour les adultes, asics gel lyte v bleu homme les plus connus sont Dracula, vampires, sorcières, sans oublier les personnages de asics gel lyte 5 concepts films effrayants.
At 11:41 PM,
5689 said…
zzzzz2018.8.25
ugg boots
kate spade handbags
ugg boots clearance
coach outlet online
coach factory outlet
coach outlet
new nike shoes
adidas outlet online
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet online
At 5:04 AM,
Yaro Gabriel said…
www1005
louboutin shoes
moncler outlet
jordan shoes
mbt shoes
ugg boots
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses
mbt shoes
ugg outlet clearance
coach outlet factory
At 9:42 PM,
jeje said…
ralph lauren polo
coach outlet online
converse trainer
canada goose
supreme clothing
adidas yeezy
jordan shoes
longchamp outlet
louboutin shoes
At 10:27 PM,
Yaro Gabriel said…
www11.12
skechers shoes
clarks outlet
canada goose
ralph lauren polo
ugg boots
coach outlet
adidas outlet
manolo blahnik
asics shoes
ralph lauren polo
Post a Comment
<< Home